Phil Plait at Bad Astromomy has a post about the recent lawsuit filed by some employees at JPL.
If you check out the comments in Wired and at Phil's journal, there's a goodly amount of people in the world that would allow the government to attach electrodes to their genitals to monitor their masturbation habits "in the name of national security."
People working on issues of national security at JPL were people who voluntarily went through high level security checks and got their Secret Level Clearances to do so. JPL provides work spaces that are specifically cleared for this purpose. It isn't just scientists, there are secretaries who have gone through the process, because, you know, you can't expect scientists to file their own shit. They're paid to do science, not order copy paper, right? Which is as it should be. People not wishing to sign any scrap of privacy away to the guvmint could go work on some other project, and there are extraordinarily few cases of national security-type projects goiing on at JPL, as far as I'm aware. I mean, if there were, they'd need a SCIF bigger than the average pantry. Or perhaps a lot of lubricant to accomodate all the bodies needing private time with their natiional security thoughts. But I digress.
I was a secretary at JPL and got out right before the badging creepiness began, and was thankfully offered a great job at a new company working for lovely humans who treat me like gold and don't require me to give up the date of my last PAP smear to order office supplies.
I was absolutely NOT a government employee at JPL. My benefits and paycheck came from Caltech. My retirement plan is with TIAA-CREF, yo. I was a government contractor.
I did not have access to any sort of sensitive data or documents. I had no access to any sort of information that would be in any way helpful to Osama, unless he needed a large supply of graph paper.
I made travel arrangements. I ordered glue sticks.
It was never made clear who would have access to our information. I wouldn't have trusted the security office with my Ralph's Club Card, let alone my medical records, and they were the folks collecting the paperwork.
HIPPA is a federal law, and it doesn't seem clear to me why the government needs access to my health records to check on whether I'm good to go ahead and restock the toner cartridges.
There are about five thousand employees at JPL. A large number of them aren't scientists and engineers with the access codes to the uranium PU-36 Space Modulator.
These are the folks who think that the internet is a series of tubes...and I'm to trust them with storing my most personal information? Seriously?
To JPL's credit, they fought tooth and nail on both this and the random drug tests, from what I've heard on the rumor circuit. (You can totally handle a class B laser while doing keg stands, but if you smoked pot while on vacation in Amsterdam last month, you're toast).
Ironically, JPL was founded by a guy who blew himself up in his garage while on a peyote vacation, and a guy who was persecuted by McCarthy during the red scare.
I would never have had the pleasure of working for JPL had this been in place when I first applied for the job. I simply wouldn't have surrendered the information and found employment elsewhere.
If another job hadn't come my way, they would have had to fire me.
It isn't silly, it isn't nothing, it isn't "no big deal." It's a slippery slope that can very easily, quietly, evolve into the Frito-Lay company making such demands on the woman who seals the bags of Flamin' Hot Cheetohs because they get their corn from a farm which receives federal subsidies.
Then you end up with the McSecurity Guards filing the paperwork and having conversations like, "Hey Bill, Maureen has bipolar and got an abortion in 1992! And Louis filed for bankruptcy and joined Gamblers Anonymous last year! Awesome!"
These things are not my employer's business, not even if my employer gets a chunk of cash from the government (which, by the way, is also me last I checked with the by the people and the for the people and MY tax dollars, too, pal), not even if my employer IS the goverment.
Someone has to push back, and I'm glad that these folks are doing that. It's a brave thing. I'm grateful to them.
Allow me to be very clear, if your job affects national security, you need a secret clearance. If your job involves thinking about the origins of the universe, Michael Griffin can try to keep that shiteating grin on his face while the theorist shoves a security badge up his doesn'tbelieveinglobalwarming ass.